Printer ink usually costs more per ounce than fine champagne, which makes finding the right cartridge feel like a high stakes financial puzzle. After analyzing the market and parsing extensive buyer feedback, I evaluated how these five popular options actually perform. My view is that sticking to genuine OEM options saves you from messy printer heads. Let us see how these contenders rank in a market filled with costly liquid.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Occasional Home Printing | ![]() |
Canon PG-245 Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Maximum Long-term Value | ![]() |
Canon PG-245 XL / CL-246 XL Genuine Ink Value Pack (2 Cartridges), Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 9.4/10 | View on Amazon |
| Heavy Black Text | ![]() |
Canon PG-245 XL Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 9.0/10 | View on Amazon |
| Budget Replacement Cartridges | ![]() |
245XL Black Ink Cartridge Compatible for Canon 245 XL PG245 (Black 2 Pack) | 8.6/10 | View on Amazon |
| Standard Printing Needs | ![]() |
Canon Genuine Ink PG-245 / CL-246 Value Pack (2 Cartridges) | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. Canon PG-245 Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
This standard cartridge earned its modest ranking by offering a dependable, lower upfront cost for households that rarely print. I think it serves as a sensible bridge for someone who only needs to output a single boarding pass every few months.
The main catch here is that standard capacity tanks drain remarkably fast if you print with any frequency. In my view, buying this version only makes financial sense if your monthly page count stays firmly in the single digits.
Users note that the standard yield requires frequent replacement if printing increases.
Buyers appreciate the lack of clogging issues associated with manufacturer ink.
Reviewers often mention wishing they had purchased the high capacity version instead.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Canon PG-245 XL / CL-246 XL Genuine Ink Value Pack (2 Cartridges), Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
This value bundle targets busy households and home offices that need both black text and color documents without constantly reordering supplies. I would recommend this pairing to anyone starting fresh who wants to secure both essential color and monochrome reserves in one box.
The bundled approach reduces your overall cost per page compared to buying separate standard cartridges. But you still face the reality of paying a steeper upfront price for genuine manufacturer supplies.
Consumers report satisfaction with getting both colors and black ink together.
Buyers frequently praise the convenience of stocking up in a single purchase.
Some reviewers note the higher initial cost can strain a small budget.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Canon PG-245 XL Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
This high-yield cartridge features a significantly larger sponge capacity that quietly doubles your printing lifespan without expanding the physical size of the hardware. I rank this as my absolute top pick because it strikes the ideal balance between page output and long-term operating costs.
You get roughly three hundred pages out of a single tank, which keeps your printer running smoothly for months of heavy paperwork. I find that the genuine reliability of this option completely justifies the initial investment.
Heavy users consistently praise the extended lifespan between replacements.
Buyers note clean, sharp text without any smudging or bleeding.
Reviewers highlight this as the most cost-effective genuine black ink choice.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 245XL Black Ink Cartridge Compatible for Canon 245 XL PG245 (Black 2 Pack)
The most common complaint about this budget-friendly alternative involves occasional printer recognition errors upon initial installation. I find that while third-party options tempt many shoppers with low price tags, they often require patience with printer software warnings.
You do receive two high-capacity cartridges for a fraction of the cost of a single original brand tank. But I must warn that print consistency can vary, and you might experience faint lines on dense documents.
Budget-focused buyers point out the impressive savings over brand-name options.
Some users report needing to reinstall the cartridges multiple times for recognition.
Reviewers mention varying print darkness compared to original manufacturer ink.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Canon Genuine Ink PG-245 / CL-246 Value Pack (2 Cartridges)
Unlike the high-yield value pack mentioned earlier, this standard pairing offers a gentler entry price for families with modest color printing habits. I view this bundle as a middle ground for users who want genuine Canon quality without committing to the larger XL tanks.
The smaller ink reservoirs mean you will visit the store or shipping site much sooner than expected. In my judgment, this set suits light multitaskers who need occasional charts and photos rather than daily document production.
Buyers note that ink levels drop quickly during photo printing.
Users appreciate having both black and color available right out of the box.
Reviewers suggest upgrading to XL versions if printing volume increases.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
When matching these options to your needs, I recommend the Canon PG-245 XL for anyone tackling heavy black text, while the Value Pack options suit households requiring occasional color. My top recommendation remains the standalone high-yield black cartridge for its unbeatable page longevity.
Remember that third-party alternatives always carry a slight risk of printer compatibility hiccups, so weigh your patience against your budget before buying.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.





